How do flat-rate shops leak money differently?
Short answer: Flat rate removes the hours leak but concentrates the leak in parts, fees, and jobs invoiced at "the standard call" regardless of what actually happened. Time-and-materials shops leak through unbilled hours; flat-rate shops leak through unbilled everything else.
The three flat-rate leak patterns
1. Parts missing from the invoice. On a flat-rate pricebook, the repair price usually assumes the part is included. But the pricebook line has to actually make it onto the invoice. A compressor swap billed as "system repair — standard" at $486 instead of "compressor replacement" at $1,620 isn't an hours problem — it's a pricebook-selection problem. The supplier statement still shows the compressor; the invoice never shows it.
2. The standard-call trap. The job ran long, the tech did real work, and the invoice says "Service call" at the standard rate. Flat-rate rules say the price book governs — but nobody maps the actual work to the right pricebook line at invoicing time. The gap between the right line and the easy line is the leak.
3. Fees that the waiver rule eats. Most flat-rate shops waive the trip charge when the repair is approved. That's the correct policy — and it means every missing fee needs a check: was there an approved repair (fine) or not (leak)? Without that check, "waived on purpose" and "forgotten" look identical.
What flat-rate shops don't leak (usually)
Hours. In time-and-materials shops, the most common leak is 6.5 hours logged vs 3.0 billed — someone rounds down, or the office trusts the tech's verbal total. Flat rate sidesteps that: the price is the price. (Except when it isn't — see the standard-call trap. That's why "flat rate" shops with T&M side work need both checks.)
A worked example
Job #20512, "condenser fan motor replacement", flat-rate shop. The pricebook line exists: MTR-COND-1/3HP — $585 installed. The invoice shows "Repair — service call" — $289.
The supplier statement shows the motor, $212, purchased the day before. The invoice exists, the customer paid, nothing looks wrong. But the right line was $585 and the easy line was $289. Residual: $296 — plus the motor, if the pricebook line already includes the part, the whole $296 is pure margin that was priced, quoted on the tablet, and never selected at invoicing.
Multiply by one job per week and it's $1,184/month.
Common mistakes
- Assuming flat rate means "nothing to check but invoices exist." The whole leak is inside the invoices — the wrong line, not the missing one.
- Auditing the pricebook instead of the invoices. The pricebook is correct; the question is whether completed work was billed from it.
- Skipping fee checks because "we're flat rate." Trip and diagnostic fees apply regardless of pricing model, and so does the waiver rule.
The check that catches it
For flat-rate shops the reconciliation question changes from "was everything billed?" to "was everything billed at the right line?" That means comparing, per job: the completed work description → the pricebook line(s) that should have applied → the lines actually invoiced. Parts reconciliation against the supplier statement stays the same.
Author: Unbilled. Our engine runs both checks and knows which applies to your billing model — it's the first question we ask. Or let us run it: send three files, get a one-page report.